So here goes another post for the blog. There are a bunch of topics we have been covering throughout our reading with Cat’s Cradle, but I think I tonight’s topic will be about the additional inferences about untruths in Cat’s Cradle and also the astonishing video we saw in class, Did You Know?
In my last post, I spoke mainly on the issue of non existing truth or a meaning to life. I got into the complications of scientific research, and how the research being done cannot be called purely true because there is nothing in the data that states this is so. Then, they use even more science and research as evidence to prove that it really is true. To summarize the post, I stated that there is nothing in the universe that will tell anyone anything about the absolute truth to life. The further I get into the novel, the more they emphasize on this concept of truth. But this time, I am beginning to see more often examples of what is said in the pretext about foma. It states “Live by the foma that make you brave and kind and healthy and happy” with foma meaning harmless untruths (Vonnegut). This can be seen in chapter 85 where John, the narrator, is searching for a term in The Books of Bokonon where he comes across the story about the solar system. It talks about Borasisi, the sun, and Pabu, the moon, creating children which were cold and did not burn, so Borasisi threw them away. They became the planets who keep their distance away from their disappointed father. But Puba decided to leave and stay with her favorite child of them all, Earth. And after this excerpt, it goes on to call it “Foma! Lie!... A pack of foma!” (Vonnegut 191) This was the story written in The Books of Bokonon. Today, people are still unsure about our endless universe and how exactly everything came into existence. The story given by Bokonon is not true, but it gives people meaning and something to believe in. Instead of just accepting that it is just there and it will always be there sort of thought process, this creates an effective way to explain things in simpler means. In postmodern terms, Bokonon’s story would fall under the concept of a local narrative.
There is also a place in the novel emphasizing this concept of truth. In this case, John meets Mona for the first time and tries to introduce himself. She responds by saying “It is not possible to make a mistake” (Vonnegut 203). This statement reveals a lot about this subject of truth and the self individual. I guess you can say that anything believed by the individual himself is subjected to be true, such as Mona’s statement with mistakes. Nothing you do can be called a mistake because an action is an action. An action becomes a mistake when the mindset of the individual, telling himself that what they did was a mistake. It is all in the perspective of the individual alone and what he believes to be true. If he believes that what he did was a mistake, then that is what it is to him. If he does not believe that what he did what he did was a mistake, then so be it. But all in all, he is the one revealing what he believes to be the actual truth. Sorry if this sounds kind of wordy and repetitive.
Well, so much for talking about the Did You Know? video. I guess I got too caught up on this subject of truths again. I did not even get to mention how I am beginning to sense another new dimension to this notion of untruths. I seem to be getting this sense of reality being more complicated than what is in front of one’s own eyes throughout Cat’s Cradle as well. This issue can wait until the next post then. Quote of the day…
“Life is really simple, but we insist on making it complicated.”
~ Confucius
Sunday, November 8, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
You know i've never commented on your blog which is kinda funny because we discuss most of this stuff anyways. But ya nice blog. You seemed to delve a lot on the topic of truth so i guess i will too. What is truth? Seems like a simple enough question right, i mean its got 3 words, so ill give a simple answer. Truth is what it is. That is what i define truth to be. Does that make it wrong? No! Others might see it as wrong but that doesn't mean i should stop believing it. Truth can mean anything to anyone. I could say truth to me is chocolate and it makes it no more wrong, or right for that matter, than if you have constructed a whole complex notion about what truth is to you. Scientists and other people (non-scientists) have different definitions of the truth. Scientists might find truth in experiments and data; tangible things. while other people might find truth in foma. Who is to say which is more right or more wrong? No one. That it the beauty of truth: it is what it is. Just came full circle i think. But anyways this is just what i am thinking at the moment and could change at any given time so ya. But on the whole, nice blog.
ReplyDeleteAnd i got a quote for ya "A chief event of life is the day in which we have encountered a mind that startled us" - Ralph Waldo Emerson. I am in no way implying that that "mind" is mine... or am I lol jk.
Hey man nice blog posting. It is always hard to start the reply, like where do i begin...so i will just start from the top. I really like your analysis on the cration myth in Cat's Cradle. You tied it in well to out past lectures, or dicussions or whatever we have in class with the Postmodernism For Beginners book. What I got out of the narratives section of Postmoderism was that people need to have an explaniation for why the universe is the way it is. You did a nice job to explain how the Books of Bokonon came up with its own creation myth saying, "Borasisi, the sun, and Pabu, the moon, creating children which were cold and did not burn, so Borasisi threw them away. They became the planets who keep their distance away from their disappointed father. But Puba decided to leave and stay with her favorite child of them all, Earth." This was such a cool explaination to read because it all made sense. I'm not even close to becoming a Bokononist, but i can appreciate how well their explanation lines up with what we see when we look in the sky at night. Also, i like how Mona is so cool in the book. How awesome would it feel going up to a super fine girl and being nervous to talk to her and she basically tells you that nothing you can say will be wrong. Now if that's not an icebreaker, then i don't know what is lol. Anyways, what you said about truth, specifically this part, "It is all in the perspective of the individual alone and what he believes to be true. If he believes that what he did was a mistake, then that is what it is to him. If he does not believe that what he did what he did was a mistake, then so be it," is a nice perspective. Truth is exactly what we make it; just like how Dr. Hoenikker feels that there was nothing immoral about bombing Hiroshima. To him this is not bad, that is his truth. So thanks for bearing with me as i carried on, see ya tomorrow.
ReplyDeleteWow! What an great blog, Andrew! Well here's all the good things I'm going to write for this first paragraph. Let's start off with the fact that you did a great job using what we talked about in class and making it connect what is in Cat's Cradle. Nice, Nice, very Nice. Oh, yeah! The meaning of how the Books of Bokonon came to live was pretty unique. It was a really entertaining passage to explain the great deatail of how it came to be. Nice, Nice, very Nice. Alright then, enough of all these nice things about what you did.
ReplyDeleteWell, here's some of what i have for my personal insights from reading your blog. Don't be afraid just go along with it. :D Okay, let's start off from the passage where you discussed about foma and narratives. Well, I have the same feelings about it too. There seems to be no truth to why we are here but just narratives which could claim us down. It is the lie which helps me live the purpose of life which i see it as. Our purpose of life just seem to be what we each do with it. I beileve that that makes us have our own purpose of life. All that scienctific research and stuff just leads on and on. Just more questions. Nothing than question which will lead to no end and will leave the mind only when death arrive.
Well, Andrew! Good job. I'll see you tomorrow for our Asian Club trip.
Andrew you have a very well thought out blog. i really enjoyed the line"It states “Live by the foma that make you brave and kind and healthy and happy” with foma meaning harmless untruths (Vonnegut)" and how you used it. i really beleive in this quote myself after having read it. it basically gives people their individuality in a way because everyone has their own personal truths they lead their life by but by no means do i think their is one absolute truth to the meaning of life. Moreover, i really thought you went into great depths with the line where you said "othing you do can be called a mistake because an action is an action. An action becomes a mistake when the mindset of the individual, telling himself that what they did was a mistake. It is all in the perspective of the individual alone and what he believes to be true."This cleary goes into the concept that people will build their own truths regardless of what others say. people will stick to what they believe is true because they feel secure and comfortable with believing such, and therefore, i think you are right they dont feel that it is a mistake because their mind is telling them that it is a truth, and that is what it will continue to be until they change their mindset if they ever do. Very good blog andrew!
ReplyDelete